The Church Renewal Podcast
The Church Renewal Podcast
The Inverse of Biblical Teamwork ⚠️
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
A meeting can sound faithful and still run on fear. We have both sat in rooms where everyone is polite, everyone says the right thing, and yet the air feels tight. The conversation moves, but nothing really gets shared. Matt calls that moment the “inverse of biblical teamwork,” and once you see it, you start spotting it in elder boards, staff meetings, ministry teams, and even Christian nonprofits.
We dig into the faulty foundation underneath it: “law doubt.” When we evaluate ourselves and one another by performance, someone else’s input starts to feel like premium speech while our own feels like discount speech. That ranking creates two unhealthy roles: the person who stays silent because they feel inferior, and the person who steamrolls because they feel superior. Either way, the team loses the “puzzle pieces” it needs for real discernment and wise church leadership.
From there, law doubt produces what we call a “fauxversation,” a table full of words that is not actually a talking with. You’ll hear how fauxversation turns into silent disagreement, quiet noncommitment, and then the predictable breakdown of accountability that ends in control games or disengaged independence. Jeremy adds a helpful overlay as we talk about idolatry, hopelessness, and fractured isolation, and why naming the pattern matters even though diagnosis is not the cure.
Grab the single-page diagram in the show notes, listen through with your team, and start building the shared language to call a time out when you slip into the inverse. If this serves you, subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review so more leaders can find it.
"community Spiritual discernment" — Matt Bohling, Flourish Coaching
The Inverse of Biblical Teamwork (diagram) — Matt Bohling and Eddie Coe, Flourish Coaching
The Five Dysfunctions of a Team — Patrick Lencioni, The Table Group
Crucial Conversations — Joseph Grenny, Kerry Patterson, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler, and Emily Gregory, Crucial Learning/McGraw Hill
Crucial Accountability — Joseph Grenny, Justin Hale, Kerry Patterson, David Maxfield, Ron McMillan, and Al Switzler, Crucial Learning/McGraw Hill
Please connect with us at our Website, Facebook, LinkedIn, and YouTube.
If you'd like to support the work of Flourish Coaching you can click here to make a donation.
Connect with Jeremy to discuss podcasting.
What Makes Someone An Expert
SPEAKER_02Matt, this is also a defining moment. What is an expert? You defined yourself as an expert.
SPEAKER_01Oh man, my favorite uh definition of an expert um is one by a turn of the 20th century uh physicist named Niels Bohr. He has a law named after him, Bohr's law. Uh-huh. And um Niels Bohr um said that um an expert is a person who's made every mistake possible within a very narrow field, to which I gladly raise my hands and admit myself into the cadre of those kinds of experts.
SPEAKER_02Well, I heard uh one definition of an expert given by a friend of mine uh at one point. He said, an expert uh is very simply taken back to the Greek. An X is a has been and the spurts that drip under pressure.
unknownHa!
SPEAKER_02There you go. There you go.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Church Renewal Podcast.
SPEAKER_02I'm Matt. I'm Jeremy.
SPEAKER_00When a group enters a difficult conversation without gospel trust, disagreement can harden into fear, suspicion, and control. We call the resulting pattern the inverse of biblical teamwork. In this episode, we'll name the faulty foundation beneath that pattern, the law
Introducing The Inverse Of Teamwork
SPEAKER_00doubt, and examine how it fractures the team that is trying to discern together.
SPEAKER_01Hi, Jarr. Hey, Matt. How are you? I'm great, man. Oh, good. It's good to see you still. It's good to see you still.
SPEAKER_02Means my one eye is still working.
SPEAKER_01That's excellent. And some of our listeners won't know that Jeremy and I live a long ways apart, and we only see each other a time or two a year. And so, anyways, we are having a good time today.
SPEAKER_02We are. We are. Matt, what are we getting into today? Wait, I'll tell you we're getting into, and I'll see if I can say this properly uh the antithesis.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's the it's the well, I have for years been calling this the inverse. The inverse, yes. Biblical teamwork. Biblical teamwork. So the inverse. That'll be next episode. We're gonna do the inverse. We're going to talk about in this episode what you have experienced more times than you would like to. We will have linked in the show notes a single page diagram of a triangle that is labeled the inverse of biblical teamwork. So you're gonna want to reference that, even if you're driving or whatever, and you can get to the show notes later and grab that single page PDF. We'll put that up there for you so that you can grab it because I'm gonna basically talk through it. So let me say again uh that this model of biblical teamwork was developed uh to what Pat Lanchone lays out in Five Dysfunctions of a Team. It certainly is an attempt to be a faithful adaptation in a biblically rooted fashion. And the inverse is also, I hope, a faithful adaptation of Pat's work, but he's not signed off on it. It's not a licensed version or something like that. It is the the product originally of me and my associate pastor Eddie Coe, and I've continued to develop it uh through the years. Um, but that's the that's the origin of it. All right, the inverse of biblical teamwork, the bad model that doesn't work that you don't want, but you've experienced probably too many times. The reason the inverse of biblical
How Law Doubt Creates Inferiority
SPEAKER_01teamwork doesn't work is because it lies in a faulty foundation.
SPEAKER_02What is that foundation?
SPEAKER_01The faulty foundation I call law doubt.
SPEAKER_02Okay. So we're getting into this right now then.
SPEAKER_01Yep. When we look at biblical teamwork, we'll talk about gospel trust. So that's the contrast here. All right, so law doubt. How does law doubt work? Here's the way that it works: Jeremy is a quite wonderful Christian whom I love and enjoy. Jeremy has a developed spiritual life that is greater than the person speaking at the moment. When I'm in the presence of somebody who I perceive to have a greater developed spiritual life than I do, I feel inferior. I feel as though I have not performed. And the person that I'm um talking to or working with has performed and has performed in a way that is greater than I have. And so that means that many times with if I'm in that posture of inferiority, which I am quite a lot, actually, because most of the people that work for me are older than more experienced than me, which is a very odd thing as a boss, right? So I'm in this position, oh, a fair degree, where I feel inferior to the person who works for me. And that's a problem. Because if I feel inferior, it means that I'm likely to go along and not speak up.
SPEAKER_02So you're not saying that the fact that you're in this position is a problem. The fact that you feel that it's inferiority.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_02That's the problem.
SPEAKER_01It's that I feel that inferiority, which of course that's not the way the Lord judges things and whatever, but I'm saying you that my human experience, right? My the places where the gospel is not yet come home yet, I can feel inferior. And what that means is that I can be too deferential and not speak my mind.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01But that's not good because the puzzle can't be made unless my hundred pieces are on the table. My hundred pieces too. Right? Not only my hundred pieces, but my hundred pieces are needed. So if I'm feeling inferior and that makes me hesitant to take my pieces out of my pocket for the puzzle that we're trying to make, the ten of us, a thousand piece puzzle, doesn't work. It breaks conversation. The group doesn't have the wisdom that it needs if I'm on the inferior side of this, because I feel like I haven't performed. And that can be morally, that can be capability, um, that can be um gifts, experience, age, anything. The oodles of things that make me feel inferior. Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01And that makes conversation incredibly difficult because I feel like you've performed, but I haven't. And so I'm not at my best, and I've elevated you above what where you should be, also. It also happens that I can end up on the superior side of this, where I feel like I'm the, well, I'm the expert. I mean, I'm the guy doing the podcast. Come on, right? I'm the guy writing the book. I'm the expert. You know, what are you talking about? Right. And and you can be very easily in my position. You can also be on the superior side of the world where you feel like I've performed, other people haven't. And so my hundred pieces should count for 995 of the pieces. Right. And you schlubs might have five more pieces, but we can see the puzzle just with what I have, right? Which is just completely not true. Maybe a little narcissistic. Um maybe a tiny bit narcissistic. That's possible that um one of the guys who trained as a coach's wife was a counselor. I was at her house when we were at her house one night for dinner, and uh, we were talking about narcissism, which I was just learning about at the time. And she looks at me with a twinkle in her eye. Counselor looks at it with a twinkle in her eye, and she's like, Aren't all pastors narcissists? I mean, who'd want to have someone looking at them every week? I was just like, touche. Newscasters and pastors. So um I can get on the superior side of this pretty easily, also, depending on you know, different setting, different group of people, whatever. But the problem is that if you're on the superior side of this, what that means is that when I'm on the inferior side of this, what comes out of your mouth, it to my my thinking comes out at a premium. And what comes out of my mouth, if I can even get it out, comes out at a discount.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I gotcha.
SPEAKER_01If I'm on the superior side of it, that's inverted. Right. What comes out of your mouth, I'm thinking about how to break down and dispense and go with, because it comes out at a discount, anyways. It's meant to be discarded. And what comes out of my mouth comes out at a premium. And if you have a group where that is their mojo, that's what I define as lawed out. Right. That they're evaluating themselves against their peers and deciding whether they're superior or inferior, trying to decide how much do I weigh what this person says? Do I say anything? Then what you end up with is something where real actual conversation
From Dialogue To Fauxversation
SPEAKER_01becomes impossible, which is the second layer in the triangle. But it the way the conversation gets broken is because of what's underneath it.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01And what's underneath it is this law of doubt.
SPEAKER_02So help me understand this concept of law doubt. Is it law doubt as if they're two an X and Y axis? Is this law of doubt a hyphenated term? And how is what you're describing here with the church?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it's this it's not a hyphenated term, it's law, doubt. And so I'm trying to distinguish between people that are relating to themselves and others on the basis of the gospel or people that are relating to themselves and others based on the law. Because the law basically is all about performance, right? Do this and you shall live. But should you not do it, you'll be cut off. You'll you'll die.
SPEAKER_02So if I'm basing my understanding on performance on law, yep.
SPEAKER_01Of myself and others. Exactly.
SPEAKER_02At the very minimum.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Okay. Absolutely. All right. I'm either doubting myself or I'm doubting you, which means that I'm also not valuing myself or valuing you. One of the disciples was always doubting Thomas. Right. Exactly. So what that means is, you know, if that's if that's the dynamic in the group, if La Dot is the dynamic in the group, the next layer up in Linchoni's heuristic is where we're talking about conversation.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01And that the dialogue is happening because you're in the space, at least in this setting, we're talking about being in the space where you're trying to do discernment, right? So the next layer up in the triangle is where dialogue happens.
SPEAKER_02So on that first layer where where you're operating out of law doubt dysfunctionally, that layer is an internal disposition towards it.
SPEAKER_01Internal disposition, it has certain thought patterns towards it. Okay. So it's a evidence that evidence itself, gotcha, right, in the looks on people's faces, their degree of attention towards other people, their willingness to speak freely, but not performatively or manipulatively, right? And so instead of the conversation sort of being free, it's incredibly constrained.
SPEAKER_02So as we're building this pyramid, if you will, you've got the starting position, the posture on the bottom of the mindset. We then have a discussion, the conversation on the second level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, discussions on the second level. Right. Exactly. So what happens is if you have this law of doubt as the foundation, it actually breaks the possibility of there being a conversation.
SPEAKER_02Completely? What?
SPEAKER_01No, not completely. Um here's here's the here's the way that I put it. So if law of doubt is prevailing and it comes time to have dialogue, what happens is we have, I've call this a faux versation.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I like it.
SPEAKER_01And the reason that it's a faux versation is it has all of the appearances of being a conversation, of a talking with, but it is not a talking with. It's a talking ad, it's a talking over, talking past, it's a talking past, right? People are not listening to hear, they're listening to respond because your viewpoint actually is not valuable, because I'm superior to you. Or if the the person over there it and I'm inferior and they think about that, they're not listening to me at all. Right. And so you end up with uh what I would call a faux versation. It has the appearance there are people around a table whose mouths are open and words are flying, but it is not a conversation, it's a faux versation. And depending on which side of that lawed out you're on, changes sort of what's in your mind as this dialogue is happening, right? So if you're a superior person, these are the kinds of things that are in your mind. Clueless, right? With an eye roll and a head turn, right? Why try? Right? If you're on the inferior side, I don't have anything to offer to this conversation. And so I'm just gonna zip it. Just gonna zip it.
SPEAKER_02Matt, this is a defining moment. What is law doubt?
SPEAKER_01Law doubt is my heart posture, my thinking process towards myself or towards somebody else where I'm evaluating
Silent Disagreement And Fear Of Conflict
SPEAKER_01whether they have performed or I have performed. And that I treat myself or others based on how they performed, not how Jesus performed in my place or their place for that matter. In Lentoni's model of this, he talks about in this layer that there can be a fear of conflict. And I think that can happen, but I think that uh a gospel foundation provides the opportunity for conflict to happen in a healthy, productive way that can take that can make that possible and welcome. Um, but people can end up in a lawed out context, especially they can be like, I am not gonna wait into that. I don't want to have a, I don't know, like conflict, I don't want to cause a conflict. Right. And it's like, it is not worth it for what that will cost. Yeah. If I do that.
SPEAKER_03For sure.
SPEAKER_01Because I know that if I try and put my pieces out there, what's gonna happen is somebody's just gonna brush them off the table.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01So who why why would I even do that to myself? What fool would do that? Right? Good question. And and so you end up with people that don't um that don't actually end up in it, they end up not in a conversation, not a talking with, not a listening to each other, but a forversation. In this uh triangle diagram in the one page that that the listener can grab off the show notes, there's a little cartoon in the upper right-hand corner that I snagged where there's a chairman standing at the head of a table uh of a gathered group, and the chairman asks, uh, all those in favor say aye. And you hear, you see below the table line, um, aye, aye, aye, aye, right? And everybody's everybody's agreeing. But it's actually silent disagreement, which is the great danger in this layer. If you have this lawed out, what you end up with is you end up with silent disagreement. Because in the bubbles above each of the men's heads around the table, here's the things that are read in the the true thoughts in their minds, not what came out of their mouth, but their true thoughts. Say it ain't so. You gotta be kidding. Parish the thought. No, a thousand times no, heaven forbid.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And that that's the real thoughts of the people. But in this setting, the leader of the group wasn't actually interested in the real thoughts. He just wanted to get something done.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I'm making the connection, but I don't want to jump ahead. Keep going.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So La Dow, what it yields in the dialogue layer is silent disagreement that sometimes comes from a fear of conflict, that conflict is not viewed as a good and helpful thing, and that we're growing in the skill of how to disagree well as Christians, because we view that it's part of how we get the wisdom that comes from above. But it takes a certain kind of gospeled people to engage that well. I recognize too that some people, just in general, over their whole life, have a conflict avoidance mindset. Yep. Um, and it's just a skill that they have not yet grown in. And the Christian church ought to be a place where we help people develop into that. Absolutely. Where they they don't become sharks, but they are willing when appropriate to disagree charitably with others. And that that's part of being a Christian. It's part of being a congregate, it's part of leading, it's part of discerning. Jesus disagreed with people. So if he did, it's possible that he might call you two.
SPEAKER_02And the book you handed me to help me in this regard, which all our listeners should know, is crucial conversation.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Or crucial accountability.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And those are both incredibly valuable. We can link to them in the show notes, and they're very, very good at helping you think about how do I have a crucial conversation with somebody. And so highly recommend it. Let's keep going. In this inverse biblical teamwork, it rests on a faulty foundation. It's why it breaks it of law doubt. If you have people that are practicing law doubt towards each other, what happens is when they get to the dialogue, it appears that a conversation is happening, but it's not actually happening. A foversation is happening. And where you walk out of is yes, maybe a decision gets made. Sometimes it actually doesn't get made. That's equally frustrating,
Noncommitment Breaks Accountability
SPEAKER_01but that's for another time. Many times the decision gets made, some kind of decision gets made. But that decision, because of the way that it was it came about, people are quietly non-committal about it.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02So that decision's either go bad or indifferent.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And and I think that the the hallmarks of a decision that was made by a group that was quietly non-committal to the decision, the hallmarks are these two quotes. Is that what we agreed on? Well, I never bought into that. And if you followed this path, when a congregant comes to you, or a staff member, if you're in a business or a nonprofit, a board member comes to you and says, Well, what do you really think about that? If you're quietly noncommittal, the temptation is very great to go, well, I didn't think it was a great idea myself. And that is the death of a group. But it is very, very easy to have happen. If this dynamic has prevailed among you, it's much easier to end up being able to peel people off. Yes. And pull them apart from the group because the group wasn't really interested in that person's viewpoint. You talked about, you know, oppressive dynamics, and this happens in groups, yeah. Where it's actually the dynamic is an oppressive dynamic. We actually are not interested. We are notitionally having a dialogue because we're supposed to. But everybody knows that the real game is that X or Y, sometimes a leader, sometimes it's somebody else dominant at the table, gets their way. And we all know that that's what's going to happen here, but it's not a real conversation. It's it's horrible to experience, but we've almost all experienced it too. Yep. And it's it's no good. If this is what's predominated and you get to this quietly non-committal, then the next layer up in Lanchone's model is is accountability. Right? Okay. And if and if this is what's predominated, you're like, I I wasn't a fan of that, anyways. Somebody tries to come and hold me accountable, screw you functionally, right? Yeah. Or I don't want to annoy him. I wasn't a fan of this anyways. He's not keeping it what we committed to. Uh I'm not gonna hold him accountable for that. And so we're we're unwilling to be held accountable, right? I don't want that, I'm gonna annoy that person. It's the same conflict avoidance, just it's just two layers up.
SPEAKER_02And so what you're left with there is is a struggle for control. Yeah, a struggle to form to cause you to to conform to whatever it is I want, yeah. Or on my part, a declared independence and uh cutting off of whatever connection I had with you that could be held accountable.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And that's what the law does. It fractures people, it doesn't bring people together. And so where you end up with when it comes to this layer that we might call commitment, is you end up with people that are quietly non-committal. Is that what we were grand on? Or I never bought into that. The hallmark of this is that the real conversation happens not around the table, but while people are standing around their cars afterwards because there wasn't the room at the time to have the real conversation, but people want real conversation, and so they find it later. And that's a hallmark that this dynamic is happening. If the real conversation can't happen in the room,
Idolatry Hopelessness And Disengagement
SPEAKER_01the leader or others in the room have made it impossible. And that needs to change because it's it's not operating in terms of biblical teamwork.
SPEAKER_02That is the inverse of biblical teamwork.
SPEAKER_01That's the inverse of biblical teamwork.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so I I will tell you and we can thank Pat Lincioni for this. I'm I'm a I'm an insightful discerner. So hopefully what I have to say here is both insightful and discerning.
SPEAKER_01That would be good.
SPEAKER_02Otherwise, I'd like to. We won't publish it if it's not. Promise. Here's what I'm here's what I'm kind of looking at what you just laid out and seeing a different transparency laid over it. On that bottom layer where where it's lawed out, I'm seeing idolatry.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02Either narcissism or idolatry of you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, something greater than the Lord's wisdom that He would give us from above is being held by me.
SPEAKER_02And I love the way that you've said in the past. You say I hold something more precious than Jesus does. Yeah. And that word precious, especially in c in the context of like Tolkien and the writing of all that, it's it's fantastic. But we get to that second level of conversation. And what I see there Okay, so my background obviously is in psychology and counseling. I've done a lot of things.
SPEAKER_03Sure.
SPEAKER_02What I see there is hopelessness. Because I'm basing everything on the law and be that doubt magnifies it's no longer about you. It's now about God. That despair, that the thing that keeps me from engaging in real conversation at that level is because I've lost hope that God's got me, that I'm protected, that he's at work here, that he has a better future than what I see. Right. And we get to the The top of this pyramid, what you called a lack of a lack of commitment, what I'm seeing there is fractured disengagement.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_02Fractured isolation.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So uninterested unfaithfulness is the is the what I have at the top of this triangle, right? So for church settings or an elder border session, and I think this is true even for a Christian business or a nonprofit, sadly, where this ends up with at the top is uninterested unfaithfulness. Oh well, I guess that's just the way it goes.
SPEAKER_02All right. Nose count and dollar count's still good.
SPEAKER_01And we see it. And I think that the church that chooses to operate this way, and obviously, this model's developed and you know I've taught it to hundreds and hundreds of people. And many times it's on the backside of painful experiences. And we're trying to help this team come together in a better way to go forward. Yeah. Right. And they're thinking back as I'm teaching this to them, they're they're thinking back and they're going, wow, we we messed that up. And we're there trying to help them regain a desire to be faithful to the Lord and to be a discerning group and how to be a biblical team instead of this. Is just way the reason that we experience this so much is that, yeah, maybe this language would be familiar to our listeners. You know, Paul talks about the the difference between, you know, life in the spirit and sort of life in the flesh, and that we're at war with the flesh. And this is the this is the fleshly way that teams tend to operate uh when the gospel is not the currency, right? It's not what we transact in. We don't transact in the gospel. And we experience this, experience this way too much, and it's very sad when it happens. One of the guys that works for me suggested that I always share this first when I do this with teams, because he said, I think that people have to sit back and go, Yeah, I've experienced that. Now I have a better sense
Naming The Problem And Holding Hope
SPEAKER_01of why I experienced that. And no, I do not want that. I don't want that any longer. I want the teams that I serve on to be different than that. Uh, and we we commend this to teams. Um, let's let's covenant together that that we're not gonna do this and that we'll we will call each other out when this is what's prevailing. We give each other permission to say, oh, hold on, time out. We have slipped into the inverse. And I've had teams where I've sat with them and we and we've done this together, and just like, oh, we slipped off that at this point, and that happened, and that's totally what it was. And it helps them sort of understand that many times a very painful experience that they've had where they've not been discerning and they fell into this. And and it, anyways, it just helps them go, yeah, that's what we don't want, but it raises their awareness, if you will, of kind of what happened and why it happened the way that it did.
SPEAKER_02Well, there's the diagnosis and the etiology goes back to the garden. Yeah. Um, but the the diagnosis is not the cure.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_02The cure we will get to when we come back next week, when we will talk about what biblical teamwork looks like. So with that in mind, please maintain hope and we look forward to sharing with you again in a week.
SPEAKER_00The inverse of biblical teamwork helps us name what happens when law doubt governs the room. But diagnosis is not the cure. In the next episode, we'll turn to the positive model and see how gospel trust allows a team to speak honestly, receive one another's contributions, and seek the wisdom of Jesus together. Thanks for listening to the Church Renewal Podcast from Flourish Coaching. Flourish exists to set ministry leaders free to be effective wherever God has called them. We believe there's only one fully sufficient reason that this day dawn, Jesus is still gathering his people and he's using his church to do it. When pastors or churches feel stuck, our team of coaches refresh their hope in the gospel and help them clarify their strategy. If you have questions or a need, we'd love to hear from you. For more information, go to our website, flourishcoaching.org, or send an email to info at floorscoaching.org. You can also connect with us on Facebook, X, and YouTube. We appreciate when you like, subscribe, rate, or review our show wherever you're listening. It can be hard for churches to ask for help, so when our clients tell us who referred them, we'll send a small gift to say thanks. Thank you to Redeemer Anglican Church in Annapolis, Maryland, for the use of their facilities to record this episode. We are humbled and grateful for your partnership. All music for this show has been licensed and was composed and created by artists. The Church Renewal podcast was directed and produced by Jeremy Sefferati in Association with Flourish Coaching, with the goal of equipping and encouraging your church to flourish wherever God has called you. Bye for now.